Menu of George's Pizza in Brookings, South Dakota, USA

Menu Overview

George's Pizza in Brookings, SD, stands as a beacon for pizza lovers and fans of Greek-inspired cuisine alike. Nestled at 311 Main Ave, this restaurant brings a warm and inviting atmosphere that perfectly complements its diverse menu. From the moment you walk in, attentive staff and cozy surroundings make you feel right at home.

The menu strikes a fine balance between classic pizza offerings and bold, Mediterranean flavors. Notably, the Greek Pizza is a standout—a thin crust base topped with gyro meat, feta cheese, green olives, and chopped garlic that bursts with vibrant flavors. This specialty pizza is both unique and comforting, with the gyro components lending a succulent, savory depth. The thin crust is especially impressive: perfectly crisp without overwhelming the toppings, creating a harmonious bite every time.

If you prefer a more traditional route, the Buffalo Chicken Pizza delivers a rich and spicy kick, layered over a pan or thin crust as you choose. Meanwhile, the signature Pepperoni Pie and Medium House Special punctuate the menu with familiar favorites expertly crafted with fresh ingredients and generous toppings.

Exploring beyond pizza, George's Pizza truly shines with its Greek-inspired sides and entrees. The Gyro with Fries and Gyro Salad come highly recommended, with a creamy cucumber sauce so thick and luscious that, as one diner remarked, you could stand a French fry upright in it. These dishes offer a refreshing counterbalance to the richer pizza options. The Greek Salad, fresh and crisp, is layered with feta and olives, making for a well-rounded taste experience.

No meal here would be complete without indulging in the Baklava, a sweet, flaky dessert that wraps up the dining experience on a perfect note. Along with the Garlic Bread Sticks and crispy fries, the sides and desserts show that George's Pizza values variety and quality across its entire spectrum.

Beverage options are straightforward, featuring a selection of beers and milk—priced reasonably at $3.00—perfect to complement the hearty dishes. The pricing model for specialty toppings, at $2.50 each, alongside one-topping pizzas starting at $11.00, reflects good value for the quality delivered.

Customer reviews consistently highlight the exceptional food quality and friendly service, despite occasional slower service moments. Theresa’s glowing praise for the chicken gyro and gyro salad’s creamy cucumber sauce, Ryan’s admiration for the Greek pizza and baklava combo, and Kyle’s excitement over the gyro-style Yoita’s pizza underscore the menu’s breadth and appeal. Even Jason’s glowing endorsement of George’s fried chicken, a featured off-menu favorite, speaks volumes about the kitchen’s versatility and dedication.

Overall, George's Pizza isn’t just a place for pizza—it’s a culinary hub where Greek and American flavors converge with skill and heart. The attention to authentic ingredients, the balance of bold and familiar flavors, and the warm ambiance makes this spot a must-visit for anyone in Brookings craving delicious, thoughtfully prepared meals.